Group Decision Making : Are the Decisions Really Made by the Group?

Home
>
Business Management
>
Group Decision Making : Are the Decisions Really Made by the Group?

Group Decision Making : Are the Decisions Really Made by the Group?

GROUP DECISION-MAKING: Many managers feel they are well-versed in areas of group effort, such as problem-solving, goal-setting, and action planning. Frequently, however, the implementation of such techniques never seem to get beyond the initial stage. Often, this is because managers can not quite seem to understand that brainstorming or group decision-making requires comprehensive utilization of various processes. Managers may unknowingly find themselves perpetuating problems instead of solving them.

DECISION BY LACK OF RESPONSE--THE PLOP METHOD: The most common-and perhaps least visible-group decision-making method is that in which someone suggests an idea and, before anyone else has said anything about it, someone else suggests another idea, until the group finds one it will act on. This results in shooting down the original idea before it has really been considered. All the ideas that are bypassed, have, in a sense been rejected by the group because the "rejections" have been simply a common decision not to support the ideas, the proposers feel that their suggestion has "plopped." The floors of most conference rooms are completely littered with plops.

DECISION BY MINORITY RULE: A single person can "enforce" a decision, particularly if they are in some kind of chairmanship role, by not giving opposition an opportunity to build up. For example, the manager might consult a few members on even the most seemingly insignificant step and may get either a negative or positive reaction. The others have remained silent. If asked how they concluded there was agreement, chances are that they will say, "Silence means consent, doesn't it? Everyone has a chance to voice opposition." If the group members are interviewed later, it sometimes is discovered that an actual majority was against a given idea, but that each one hesitated to speak up because she thought that all the other silent ones were for it. They too were trapped by "silence means consent."

WHAT IS WRONG? OTHER PROBLEMS IN GROUP DECISION MAKING: First, the minority members often feel that there was an insufficient period of discussion for them to really get their point of view across; hence they feel misunderstood and sometimes resentful. Second, the minority members often feel that the voting has created two camps within the group, and that these camps are now in win-lose competition: The minority feels that their camp lost the first round but that it is just a matter of time until it can regroup, pick up some support, and win the next time a vote comes up. In other words, voting creates coalitions, and the preoccupation of the losing coalition is not how to implement what the majority wants, but how to win the next battle. If voting is to be used, the group must be sure that it has created a climate in which members feel they have had their day in court, and where all members feel obligated to go along with the majority decision.

Copyright AE Schwartz & Associates All rights reserved. For additional presentation materials and resources: ReadySetPresent and for a Free listing as a Trainer, Consultant, Speaker, Vendor/Organization: TrainingConsortium

CEO, A.E. Schwartz & Associates, Boston, MA., a comprehensive organization which offers over 40 skills based management training programs. Mr. Schwartz conducts over 150 programs annually for clients in industry, research, technology, government, Fortune 100/500 companies, and nonprofit organizations worldawide. He is often found at conferences as a key note presenter and/or facilitator. His style is fast-paced, participatory, practical, and humorous. He has authored over 65 books and products, and taught/lectured at over a dozen colleges and universities throughout the United States.

In The News:

Mines Management Inc. : Prepares for Exploration on La Estrella Gold-Silver ...
Reuters
RELEASE 12-05 MINES MANAGEMENT PREPARES FOR EXPLORATION ON LA ESTRELLA GOLD-SILVER PROJECT Spokane, Washington - May 25, 2012 - Mines Management, Inc. (NYSE-Amex: "MGN", TSX: "MGT") (the "Company") is pleased to announce preparations, ...
Mines Management Inc. : Update - Prepares For Exploration On La Estrella Gold ...MarketWatch (press release)

all 8 news articles »

Management Tip of the Day: Hire for passion
Reuters
The Management Tip of the Day offers quick, practical management tips and ideas from Harvard Business Review and HBR.org (www.hbr.org). Any opinions expressed are not endorsed by Reuters. "People are more creative when they feel passionate about their ...

and more »

Apollo Global Management Completes Acquisition of EP Energy
MarketWatch (press release)
Sam Oh, partner at Apollo, stated, "We are delighted to partner with one of North America's leading exploration and production franchises led by a world class team of managers. Our acquisition of EP Energy solidifies Apollo's natural resources platform ...

and more »

New York Magazine
JPMorgan Chase Risk Management Committee Missing Bank Directors, Financial ...
Huffington Post
What the committee's missing that all the other big banks have: people who worked as financial risk managers. The makeup of JPMorgan's committee hasn't changed since 2008, but the bank was warned last year that it wasn't up to the task of monitoring ...
JP Morgan's Risks Aren't Well-Managed Because JP Morgan Doesn't Want Sound ...Slate Magazine (blog)

all 13 news articles »

SAS in Leaders Quadrant of Magic Quadrant for CRM Multichannel Campaign Management
MarketWatch (press release)
CARY, NC, May 25, 2012 (BUSINESS WIRE) -- SAS is in the Leaders quadrant in Gartner Inc.'s latest, "Magic Quadrant for CRM Multichannel Campaign Management"(1) This places SAS, the leader in business analytics and integrated marketing management, ...

and more »

VIP Wins Project Management Contract for California Secretary of State
MarketWatch (press release)
SACRAMENTO, CA, May 25, 2012 (MARKETWIRE via COMTEX) -- The California Secretary of State awarded Visionary Integration Professionals (VIP) a contract for just under $1 million to provide project management services for the California Business Connect ...

and more »

Strategic Information Management Provider Stibo Systems Achieves Record Growth
MarketWatch (press release)
Stibo Systems, the Strategic Information Management Company, today announced significant financial growth highlighted by new customer contracts, additional deployments from existing clients, and expansion into new vertical industries and geographies ...

and more »

Bloomberg
Dell Said to Weigh Buying Quest to Add Computer-Management Tools
BusinessWeek
By Serena Saitto and Aaron Ricadela on May 25, 2012 Dell Inc. (DELL) (DELL) is in discussions to acquire Quest Software Inc. (QSFT) (QSFT), a maker of tools that help companies manage their computer systems, according to people with knowledge of the ...
Dell Said to Mull Buying Quest for Computer-Management ToolsSan Francisco Chronicle
Dell's Quest For Software Business Could Lead To Acquiring Quest SoftwareCRN
Would Quest buy help Dell?GigaOM
Channelnomics -Forbes -Investor's Business Daily
all 45 news articles »

TheBull.com.au
Sims Metal Management Market Update for Fiscal 2012
MarketWatch (press release)
CHICAGO & SYDNEY, May 24, 2012 (BUSINESS WIRE) -- Sims Metal Management Limited (the "Company") advises that basis the continuation of global economic challenges and headwinds, and with only 10 months results known at this point, that full year ...
Sims Metal Management shares dive after profit warningHerald Sun
Sims Metal savaged on earnings warningThe Australian
From Earlier: Sims Metal Management Market Update for Fiscal 2012Benzinga

all 59 news articles »

TEXT-Fitch affirms SCB Asset Management at 'M2+(tha)'
Reuters
(To remove the RIC SCB.BK which was wrongly inserted beside text) (The following statement was released by the rating agency) May 25 - Fitch Ratings (Thailand) has affirmed Thailand-based SCB Asset Management Co., Ltd.'s (SCBAM) National Asset Manager ...

and more »

Google News