What Do Trees Have to Do With Golf?

Home
>
Golf
>
What Do Trees Have to Do With Golf?

What Do Trees Have to Do With Golf?

On our way back from a recent round of golf, Fritz and I were discussing the way most golfers evaluate golf courses. We've had this discussion before, and it inevitably gets around to my heartfelt conviction that trees do not enhance the "golfing experience".

Most golfers in North America assume that golf is not golf without tree-lined fairways. If I am not mistaken, this is a bias created by a century of golf course design compliments of a relatively small number of trend-setting designers. In Canada, Stanley Thompson was the main man. His course designs can be found across the country, and inevitably they feature lush green (soft) fairways lined with majestic trees.

Of course there are many reasons for this, both practical and esthetic. For starters, eastern North America has lots of trees, and just as important, it is impossible to replicate the sandy turf of Scotland or Ireland in other parts of the world that do not share the same climate.

Nevertheless it struck me as a bit odd when on a recent trip to Saskatchewan we found the same type of fairways in that relatively dry prairie climate as we have here in our much more humid environment in southern Ontario.

What we have seen in first half of the last century was a progression from the use of native grasses in a place like St. Andrews or Dornoch, Scotland to the use of highly manipulated hybrids like bentgrass in Ontario, where the climate can (more or less) support them (with constant watering, of course).

But rather than using native grasses in the prairie or semi-desert settings of the North American western plain, course designers in those regions seem to have imported the ideas developed in the east. Especially the use of trees and non-native grasses.

One course we played near Elbow, Saskatchewan had water lying around from the overnight watering. This was in spite of the recent rainy period in the area. And while the greens seemed to be holding up well, they were typically left quite long and shaggy so they could withstand the inevitable dry spell that was just around the corner.

Seems to me there should be native grasses that would do better than this. Of course I could be completely wrong...

My point is that golf course design in North America has often created synthetic environments that alienate the golfer from the native terrain and turf. Which gets me back to trees...

To my way of thinking, that trees should come into play during a round of golf seems an unfortunate departure from the original way the game was conceived. Once you play a bit of links golf you realize that the game was originally meant to be played by running the ball along the ground. Like curling, that other Scottish obsession, the game represents an attempt to control the way the ball (stone) interacts with the course (ice).

In the first 100 years or so of golf in North America we have tried to take this element out of the game by making sure that the ground remains soft, that the grass is as green and lush as possible, and that there are as many strategically placed trees as possible to get in the way of our drives and approach shots.

On the other hand, trees are an important part of the native landscape in many parts of North America, so I would be contradicting myself if I said they should not be part of a "natural" layout in eastern North American. I am not advocating the "denuding" of the landscape in order to create a pseudo links-like environment. But trees should remain strictly in the background as far as I am concerned. Thankfully, this seems to be the way golf course design has been moving for the last 15 years or so.

From Golf Stories at Internetgolfreview.com

Visit the article section at Internetgolfreview.com for more golf stories, articles and golf travel features.

Rick Hendershot is a writer, avid golfer creator of the Linknet Publishing Network. For online advertising opportunities, visit Linknet advertising options.

In The News:

Fort Worth Star Telegram
Golf • 'Lucky' Zach Johnson leading by a stroke at the Colonial
Salt Lake Tribune
"I kept the golf course in front me. I attacked when I could attack. I had a couple of nice saves when I needed it. … I've got zero complaints." Jason Dufner, rookie Harris English, Tom Gillis and Kyle Reifers were tied for second.
Golf CapsulesWashington Post
UPDATE 1-Golf-Johnson sets Colonial pace, Dufner one behindChicago Tribune
Johnson Holds One-Shot Lead at Crowne Plaza Invitational GolfBloomberg
Fort Worth Star Telegram -ESPN (blog)
all 646 news articles »

SB Nation
Golf roundup: Johnson leads at Colonial
Austin American-Statesman
As part of a technology change, commenting will not be available on some articles for a number of months. Read more about the change here. ASSOCIATED PRESS FORT WORTH — Zach Johnson made two clutch par-savers that were part of a bogey-free, 6-under ...
McDowell stunned by 'freak' incident at WentworthUSA TODAY
Frustrated Rory McIlroy Throws Golf Club -- Just Like Tiger WoodsSB Nation
Golf-Drysdale, Lawrie steal show at sunny WentworthReuters UK
Pakistan Daily Times
all 1,151 news articles »

Bradenton Herald
Airplane door falls onto golf course
CNN
By Aaron Cooper, CNN Washington (CNN) -- The FAA is investigating what caused a private jet to lose its door as it flew over a Florida golf course. The Canadair CL600 jet was traveling from Opa-Locka to Pompano Beach, Florida, on Wednesday when it was ...
Private jet door lands on South Florida golf course fairway; no injuries reportedWashington Post
Plane door falls from sky and lands on Hallandale Beach golf courseMiamiHerald.com
Odd hazard for Diplomat golf course as plane door falls from skySun-Sentinel

all 99 news articles »

Purdue Boilermakers
UNC second at NCAA golf championship
News & Observer
North Carolina women's golf team is tied for second place following the second round of the NCAA Championships. North Carolina fired a 4-over-par 292 on Tuesday at the Vanderbilt Legends Club and moved to 6-over for the tournament, 11 strokes behind ...
Baylor Women's Golf Tied for 18th At NCAA'sKWTX
Strauss paces Women's Golf in NCAA Championship third roundTexasSports.com
Women's Golf In Ninth At NCAA ChampionshipsPurdue Boilermakers
Seminoles.com -SportsPageMagazine.com -TarHeelBlue.com
all 233 news articles »

al.com
Alabama women's golf team sees big lead shrink to two shots going into final ...
al.com
(UA photo) Just when it looked as if the second-ranked Alabama women's golf team might run away with its first national championship, along came USC. And there went most of the second-ranked Crimson Tide's big second-round lead.
Tide Women's Golf Still in First Place at NCAAsCBS42
'Nothing to lose' at NCAA golfGoVolsXtra
Alabama barely hangs onto lead at NCAA golf championshipsThe Tennessean
Montgomery Advertiser
all 250 news articles »

USA TODAY
Tiger's fall has left void in golfing greatness
STLtoday.com
Tiger Woods, left, and Jim Furyk speak on the 11th tee during final round of the Players Championship golf tournament at TPC Sawgrass, Sunday, May 13, 2012, in Ponte Vedra Beach, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara) Parity and dissemination can be good.
Tiger Woods thinks he can compete well into his 50sCBSSports.com (blog)
Truth and Rumors: Will Tiger play golf into his 50s?Golf.com (blog)
PAUL WOODY: Tiger Woods' most important achievements are off the golf courseRichmond Times Dispatch
Larry Brown Sports
all 137 news articles »

Golf Tidbits: English breaks out at Open qualifier
Fox News
Philadelphia, PA – Following an appearance at the Walker Cup last year, Harris English knew one thing - he wanted to do everything he could to qualify for the British Open because he loved playing golf in Scotland. No one knew it would be this easy.

and more »

Golf: Edmond's Rhein Gibson looks back on Guinness World Record round
NewsOK.com
The lowest round of golf ever recorded was shot by an Oklahoma transplant from Australia. Rhein Gibson, a former NAIA All-American at Oklahoma Christian, shot a 55 at River Oaks Golf Club two weeks ago. It's the Guinness World Record.
Freedom 55, Aussie-StyleOttawa Citizen (blog)

all 3 news articles »

Is Golf a Sport? ProCon.org Tees Up Controversy with New Sports Website
Sacramento Bee
By ProCon.org SANTA MONICA, Calif., May 24, 2012 -- /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Golf in the United States is a $76 billion industry with 25.7 million players. Thirty-eight percent of Americans call themselves golf fans. Golf is clearly popular, ...

and more »

Boys golf: Ridgewood ends spring on a 'positive note'
NorthJersey.com
BY RON FOX RIDGEWOOD — The just-completed high school golf season was literally a lesson in life for the Ridgewood High School boys team. "It's been a strange season," head coach Dave Jenkins said four days after the Maroons finished in the middle of ...

and more »

Google News