The Views of Karl Marx VS Max Weber

Home
>
Ethics
>
The Views of Karl Marx VS Max Weber

The Views of Karl Marx VS Max Weber

Compare and contrast the views of Karl Marx and Max Weber with regards as to what motivates people to work.

Karl Marx:
[1] Exploitation

[2] Proletariat have to sell their labour-power

[3] The machines of the industrial revolution eliminate creativity require only the workers own labour, work is alienated, workers alienated.

Max Weber:
[1] Regarded as one of the 'founding fathers' of sociology

[2] Wider analysis of capitalism then that of Marx

[3] Weber ignores labour exploitation as being a function of class

Compare:
[1] Calvinism can be seen to have provided the initiating force for capitalism in as much as the effects of Calvinism that originated in theology reflect the spirit for capitalism (the drive for economic success).

[2] Ownership and control through capitalism

[3] Mark uses exploitation and oppression of the working classes (proletariat). as a means for exercising control by manipulation the situation.

[4] Weber uses bureaucratic organization as a means for exercising control by calculated acts of influence.

[5] Abolition of control and capitalists that cannot exist without wage-workers would create a Utopian Socialism where superstition, injustice, privilege, oppression, were to be superseded by equality

Contrast:
[1] Marx explained social phenomena in primarily economic terms (necessary to survive)

[2] Weber Explained social phenomena in cultural terms.

[3] Mark Focussed on group rather than individual action (trade unions, workplace organizations).

[4] Weber focussed on individual social action and interaction

[5] For Marx the key influences of motivation are greed, alienation, exploitation, labour/manager distinction

[6] Weber see motivation as a function of technical problems to be overcome

[7] Marx suggests that religion provides justification for the status quo and relief for suffering in the material world.

[8] Weber suggests that religion directs its followers to gain salvation by doing 'good works' and 'hard work' in the material world.

Conclusion:
It could be said therefore that Marx has the paranoid belief that only the baser instincts of greed alienation and exploitation motivate work, and that religion is the camouflage that conceals the truth of this, Weber has the opposing view that motivation comes from the individuals wish to overcome problems, supported by the religious work ethic to do good for the common good.

I am the website administrator of the Wandle industrial museum (http://www.wandle.org). Established in 1983 by local people determined to ensure that the history of the valley was no longer neglected but enhanced awareness its heritage for the use and benefits of the community.

In The News:

ProPublica
Ethics group urges investigators to probe lobbyist involved in Owens trip
WatertownDailyTimes.com
By BRIAN AMARAL A public ethics watchdog wants federal ethics investigators to probe a lobbying firm that arranged Rep. William L. Owens's trip to Taiwan. In a letter sent Wednesday to the Office of Congressional Ethics, officials from Public Citizen ...
Owens Welcomes Ethics ProbeWWNY TV 7

all 4 news articles »

USA TODAY
Justice ethics report finds misconduct by Stevens prosecutors
Anchorage Daily News
By PETE YOST AP WASHINGTON — The Justice Department's internal ethics watchdog said Thursday that two prosecutors in the bungled corruption case against then-Sen. Ted Stevens engaged in reckless professional misconduct by failing to disclose ...
Ted Stevens Case: Justice Department Says Two Prosecutors Engaged In MisconductHuffington Post
Justice Dept. probe finds misconduct by prosecutors in Stevens trialCNN International
Justice Dep't: Misconduct by 2 in Stevens caseWBRC

all 249 news articles »

McKenna faces 2 ethics complaints over county work
The Seattle Times
A lawyer and a citizen have each filed ethics complaints against Republican gubernatorial candidate Rob McKenna. The Associated Press Note to Kyle Olive and Kimberly Christensen (and the note would be the same regardless... (May 24, 2012, by Creasy ...
McKenna faces ethics complaint over county workThe Columbian

all 22 news articles »

Man leading ethics probe of Baptist leader resigns
The Daily Advance
(AP) — The head of a group investigating the comments of Southern Baptist Convention ethics leader Richard Land has resigned. Arkansas pastor Richard Piles said he has taken over as Trustee Board chairman for the Ethics and Religious Liberty ...
Southern Baptist committee head resigns in Richard Land ethics caseThe Tennessean
Investigation re: Baptist spokesman's commentsOneNewsNow

all 67 news articles »

Board Dismisses Ethics Complaint Against Two Aldermen
Patch.com
There is no conflict of interest by members of the Common Council also serving on the Waukesha County Board of Supervisors, Ethics Board rules. By Sarah Millard Alderwoman Kathleen Cummings, sitting, listens to the Ethics Board discuss a complaint ...

and more »

The Guardian
News Summary: News Corp. lobbyist testifies on UK government contacts to ...
Washington Post
ETHICS PANEL: Lobbyist Fred Michel talked Thursday to the Leveson Inquiry into media ethics that the British government created because of the hacking scandal. Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published ...
British Inquiry Questions Murdoch LobbyistNew York Times
Adviser pulls Cameron into storm over HuntFinancial Times
British PM David Cameron appointed 'known Murdoch supporter'The Australian
Huffington Post -Ventura County Star
all 1,273 news articles »

Ex-SEC Attorney Barred for 1 Year Over Stanford Ethics Lapse
BusinessWeek
Spencer Barasch, who participated in the SEC's investigation of R. Allen Stanford's $7 billion Ponzi scheme, performed private legal work for Stanford Group Co. about a year after leaving the agency even though its ethics office had told him he was ...
SEC sanctions ex-staffer who represented Stanford CoReuters
SEC Bars Former SEC Employee On Alleged Conflict Of InterestWall Street Journal

all 4 news articles »

Essex County Ethics board reprimands Keene super
Plattsburgh Press Republican
ELIZABETHTOWN — The Essex County Ethics Committee issued a decision reprimanding Keene's supervisor for using town gas. Its findings came Thursday after a six-week review, saying the committee believes Bill Ferebee's use of 14 gallons from the town ...

Ethics should guide Vanderbilt investments
The Tennessean
Thousands more participated in the movement for ethical investment by producing, showing and sharing media, and hosting dozens of teach-ins including a march on the Board of Trust in November and a teach-in with more than 50 faculty and students at the ...

and more »

Boynton expense fund is an ethics risk, county says
Sun-Sentinel
A Palm Beach County ethics officer said recently that restrictions on the reimbursement funds are ambiguous and elected officials don't have to report how they spend it. And while nothing requires them to return extra money, keeping it would be a ...

and more »

Google News