Are Obese Women Getting Short-Changed By Chemotherapy Treatments?

Home
>
Breast Cancer
>
Are Obese Women Getting Short-Changed By Chemotherapy Treatments?

Are Obese Women Getting Short-Changed By Chemotherapy Treatments?

How much chemotherapy does an obese woman need? Typically an obese woman with breast cancer would receive reduced doses of chemotherapy as they battle breast cancer.

Back in June of 2005, a study published in the Archives of Internal Medicine concluded that obese women should receive chemotherapy based on their actual weight, and not in reduced as amounts as it the standard practice.

And now again a study presented in the August 2005 edition of Lancet claims that doctors should not reduce chemotherapy doses for obese women when no receptors for the hormone oestrogen have been found on the breast cancer cells. This type of cancer is called oestrogen-receptor negative.

Clinicians often reduce chemotherapy doses for obese patients because of worries about how the treatment may react with the patient and affect their overall health.

According to the study's director Marco Colleoni of the European Institute of Oncology, Italy, and his colleagues, reducing the first course of chemotherapy for obese patients with oestrogen-receptor negative breast cancer proves "detrimental".

Colleoni and his team looked at the relation between body-mass index (BMI), chemotherapy dose reduction, oestrogen receptor expression, and outcome for pre-menopausal women with breast cancer by examining data from four randomized trials.

They found that 97 out of 249 obese patients received less than 85% of protocol specified dose during the first course of chemotherapy compared with patients with normal and intermediate BMI.

Obese patients with oestrogen-receptor negative disease that received 85% or more of the first protocol specified dose had significantly better disease-free survival and overall survival than those who received less than 85% of the normally recommended dosage.

Yet, obese patients with oestrogen-receptor positive breast cancer who had reduced doses of chemotherapy did not have a significant difference in their outcome compared with those given the recommended chemotherapy doses.

And contrary to popular practice, the researchers also noticed that obese patients initially treated with protocol doses of chemotherapy did not have more toxicity than patients who received reduced doses.

Dr Marco Colleoni concluded that, "Our findings suggest that for women with ER-absent or ER-low tumours, reduction in chemotherapy dose should be avoided."

The message for obese women coping with cancer is to be aware of your risks and rights. Ask your doctor will she recommend lower doses of chemotherapy for you based on your weight and ask why.

Resources: Lancet, Archives of Internal Medicine

Health author and Stanford University graduate Naweko San-Joyz lovingly writes from her home in San Diego. Her works include Acne Messages: Crack the Code of Your Zits and Say Goodbye to Acne (ISBN: 0974912204) and Skinny Fat Chicks, Why We're Still Not Getting This Dieting Thing (ISBN: 0974912212). Naweko created the Noixia philosophy to help people enhance their lives by connecting with their inner-mysteries and inner-selves. Her works take often over-looked, yet viable research and transforms in into practical tools that people can use to improve their health. Get useful, but too often ignored women's health news by visiting http://www.Noixia.com, Where Beauty Means Health.

In The News:

Medical Tactile, Inc. Announces a 3G-Wireless System for Breast Cancer Screening
MarketWatch (press release)
According to a publication funded by the Susan G. Komen Foundation, 1.6 million women worldwide were diagnosed with breast cancer in 2010 and 425000 women died from the disease. Although early detection is the best means to a good prognosis for breast ...

and more »

Al-Arabiya
Rusty Link: The Lackluster Science Behind the Abortion–Breast Cancer Connection
Slate Magazine
Now, providers there must inform pregnant women about “the possibility of increased risk of breast cancer following an induced abortion,” the so-called ABC link. In the decade following Roe v. Wade, the occurrence of breast tumors in the United States ...
Saudi women take fight against breast cancer to Mount EverestAl-Arabiya
Breast cancer advocacy organizations target the under 45 patientThe Imperfect Parent
A woman's journey: destination Mount EverestPakistan Daily Times
New Zealand Herald -The Voice of Russia -HealthTechZone
all 12 news articles »

Jagran Post
Moderate Weight Loss Can Decrease Breast Cancer Risk
ABC News
Could moderate weight loss lower your chance of developing breast cancer? Researchers from the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center think it's possible. The connection between obesity and breast cancer risk in women after menopause has long been ...
Dropping a Few Pounds Could Lower Breast Cancer RiskTIME
Small weight loss effectively reduces sex hormones linked with breast cancerFox News
Dieting May Lower Hormone Levels Tied to Breast CancerU.S. News & World Report
Jagran Post -Globe and Mail -Seattle Post Intelligencer
all 54 news articles »

ABC15.com (KNXV-TV)
Questions about Valley breast cancer charity, where donation money is really used
ABC15.com (KNXV-TV)
When Pat Elliot of Phoenix received what she called an "aggressive" call from a telemarketer representing The Breast Cancer Society, Inc., she was concerned. “It does not appear that patients with breast cancer are being served,” she said.

and more »

Firstpost
New breast cancer test to predict return of tumour post surgery
Daily News & Analysis
A breast cancer test that could spare thousands of women the ordeal of chemotherapy could be available in the UK this year. The test costs just £120 a time and can accurately predict whether a tumour is likely to return after it has been surgically ...
Now, a breast cancer test to predict if tumour will recurBusiness Standard
Find out cheap if breast cancer tumour will returnFirstpost

all 10 news articles »

Galena Biopharma's Breast Cancer Vaccine Sprouts More Red Flags
TheStreet.com
By Adam Feuerstein 05/22/12 - 02:23 PM EDT LAKE OSWEGO, Oregon (TheStreet) -- More red flags have been found staked into Galena Biopharma's(GALE) breast cancer vaccine NeuVax. Updated, 60-month follow-up results from a Neuvax phase II study scheduled ...
Galena Biopharma With Near Term ASCO CatalystSeeking Alpha

all 2 news articles »

Breast cancer clinical trial tests combo of heat shock protein inhibitor and ...
Medical Xpress
Researchers have theorized that inhibiting HSP90 just might render breast cancer cells less likely to escape the challenge posed by cutting off their ability to use estrogen. Such is the rationale for a new clinical trial that has begun enrolling ...

and more »

Breast MRI helps predict chemotherapy's effectiveness
Medical Xpress
Women with breast cancer often undergo chemotherapy prior to surgery. Research has shown that women who receive this treatment, known as neoadjuvant chemotherapy, are more likely to achieve breast conservation than those receiving chemotherapy after ...
Breast MRI and Chemo EffectivenessIvanhoe

all 5 news articles »

Keeping breast cancer at bay: Doctors from China train at CentraState
News Transcript
PHOTO COURTESY OF CENTRASTATE MEDICAL CENTER Seven physicians from China traveled to New Jersey recently to learn about the latest imaging and interventional techniques to diagnose breast cancer as early as possible. From April 30 to May 5, ...

Sydney Morning Herald
Benefits of Hormone-Replacement Therapy Outweigh Risks, Reviews of Studies Show
Wall Street Journal (blog)
Much of that big government study was halted in July 2002 after data suggested that women taking estrogen-and-progestin replacement had a higher rate of heart disease, stroke and breast cancer than those on a placebo. Millions of women and their ...
Doctors rethink hormone therapySydney Morning Herald
Call for 'rational use' of hormone therapy near menopauseNew Zealand Herald
The rollercoaster ride of menopauseFond du Lac Reporter
WebMD.Boots.com -Telegraph.co.uk
all 190 news articles »

Google News